Property vs gold: which comes out ahead in the long run?

News

Property and gold have a lot in common for private investors. Both are, ideally at least, long-term investments, and both are meant to act as a store of value that helps cushion financial uncertainty and inflation over many years. It is no coincidence that bricks and mortar are often called “concrete gold” in German-speaking markets. Although the two asset classes are not necessarily seen as rivals, it is interesting to compare how property and gold have performed against each other, and over a long period. A study by the financial platform “LongtermTrends” has done exactly that for the US market.

Taking the US dollar out of the equation

The Home Price Index created by Robert Shiller and Karl Case in 1890 forms the basis of the “Real Estate to Gold Ratio”, which shows how many ounces of gold it takes to buy a private home that is average in every respect. The US currency itself is not part of the ratio, so no adjustment for inflation is needed, which also makes historical comparisons possible. When the ratio began on 1 January 1890, it took 388 ounces of gold to buy an average house. After the Second World War and during the Bretton Woods era, the ratio climbed as high as 1,009 ounces, to gold’s disadvantage. In 1976, 50 years ago, it took 370 ounces of gold to buy a property. On 10 November 2026, it was 149 ounces.

Since 2000: ratio swings in gold’s favour

In 2000, an average home cost just under 700 ounces of gold. Currently, that amount buys 4.7 homes. Both investments have proved their worth as a store of value over the long term: private property has gained around 1,075 per cent in value over the past 50 years, while gold has gained far more, at just under 4,000 per cent.